| Adlai Stevenson I | Phi Delta Theta |
| Alben W. Barkley | Delta Tau Delta |
| Calvin Coolidge | Phi Gamma Delta |
| Charles G. Dawes | Delta Upsilon |
| Charles W. Fairbanks | Phi Gamma Delta |
| Chester A. Arthur | Psi Upsilon |
| Dan Quayle | Delta Kappa Epsilon |
| Garret Hobart | Delta Phi |
| George H. W. Bush | Delta Kappa Epsilon |
| Gerald Ford | Delta Kappa Epsilon |
| Harry S. Truman | Lambda Chi Alpha & Alpha Delta Gamma** |
| Henry Agard Wallace | Delta Tau Delta |
| Hubert Humphrey | Phi Delta Chi & Alpha Phi Alpha** |
| James Schoolcraft Sherman | Sigma Phi |
| John Nance Garner | Pi Kappa Alpha |
| Mike Pence | Phi Gamma Delta |
| Nelson Rockefeller | Psi Upsilon |
| Schuyler Colfax | Beta Theta Pi** |
| Theodore Roosevelt | Delta Kappa Epsilon & Alpha Delta Phi |
| Thomas Riley Marshall | Phi Gamma Delta |
