| Rutherford B. Hayes | Delta Kappa Epsilon** |
| James Garfield | Delta Upsilon |
| Chester A. Arthur | Psi Upsilon |
| Grover Cleveland | Sigma Chi* |
| Benjamin Harrison | Phi Delta Theta & Delta Chi |
| William McKinley | Sigma Alpha Epsilon |
| Theodore Roosevelt | Delta Kappa Epsilon & Alpha Delta Phi |
| William Howard Taft | Psi Upsilon |
| Woodrow Wilson | Phi Kappa Psi |
| Calvin Coolidge | Phi Gamma Delta |
| Franklin D. Roosevelt | Alpha Delta Phi** |
| Harry S. Truman | Lambda Chi Alpha & Alpha Delta Gamma** |
| Dwight D. Eisenhower | Tau Epsilon Phi |
| John F. Kennedy | Phi Kappa Theta |
| Gerald Ford | Delta Kappa Epsilon |
| Ronald Reagan | Tau Kappa Epsilon |
| George H. W. Bush | Delta Kappa Epsilon |
| Bill Clinton | Phi Beta Sigma** |
| George W. Bush | Delta Kappa Epsilon |
